My 8 year old is a Striker. Why are you playing him at the back?

I have always been a strong advocate that it is beneficial for young players (U16 & younger) to play in many positions when they are developing as footballers. I believe it benefits them because firstly I believe it makes them better footballers and secondly it allows them to enjoy playing football for longer as they have a broad enough education in football to adapt to each football environment they encounter.

Now it is time for me to state my case for this long held belief and see if I still believe it.

I am revisiting this because a 9 year player has left the club I work at simply because it is our policy to rotate players through positions at that age. He has moved to a club that has ‘guaranteed’ he will play centre midfield every game.

For the sake of this blog if I assume that all clubs have identical quality training sessions plus identical coaching and playing styles and only differ on this point then what benefits come solely from playing in a variety of positions?

These are in no particular order

1 – Walk a mile in my shoes

Surely a player will have a greater understanding of how to assist a team mate or exploit an opponent playing in a position if they have experienced the difficulties or nuances of those positions first hand i.e A midfielder understanding that the full back will struggle to get back into position if they have overlapped the forwards and so move to cover that position in case the attack breaks down.

2 – You’ll never know if you never give it a go

A player might really enjoy or have an aptitude for playing a certain position but if they never get to try it then they will never find out. With the reduced amount of informal play now I can imagine there are few opportunities to experience different positions if your club team insists on giving you a set position.

It is a real source of annoyance with me that left footed youth players in particular seem to be assigned a left sided position immediately and often never get to play anywhere else because they give ‘balance’ to the team.

3 – Player’s playing experience

There is a world of difference playing football when the game is mostly to the side of you, in front of you or when it is all around you. A player has to position themselves differently to find space, they have to scan differently and with different frequencies plus they have different amounts of time to execute what they want to do depending on where they are on the pitch.

If you always play in a set position surely the range of technical skills you get to practice is also limited i.e the most obvious being defensive players would rarely get to practice taking a player on.

4 – Versatility

The coach decides to switch formations and your previous position no longer exists. The playing experience from your previous set position may not help you find a new position in the new formation. If you have to move to a central role from a role on the flanks or from a defensive position into a more advanced position. Can you learn the new role quick enough with its different requirements or are you discarded for a new player.

A new player joins the team and they are better at playing the only position you have ever played than you.

5 – Suitability for a position

A player might have the requirements to play a position in youth football due to early maturation, pitch size, no offside rule, opposition player’s lack of technique or whatever factors but by the time they are ready for senior football they may be totally unsuited for that position.

These are the reasons that came to mind for players rotating positions but obviously I need to hear from Coaches who feel playing in a set position from an early age and sticking to it is more beneficial. I would also like to hear from Coaches who have different reasons for rotating players.

Hope everyone had a great Christmas and New Year.

Look forward to hearing from you

Please leave a comment or email me seanthecoach@icloud.com

Follow me on Twitter @SeanDArcy66

Till next time

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “My 8 year old is a Striker. Why are you playing him at the back?

  1. Hi Sean
    Your comments are valid but I doubt an 8 or 9 year old will relate to most of them. Sometimes you have to put the kids hat on and take your adult cap off. Steven Covey said, seek first to understand others and it’s good advice I try to apply. If kids don’t enjoy the experience they will often leave the situation.
    All the best.
    Ron

    Like

    • I understand what you are saying and it is definitely a different situation if the child simply stops enjoying playing football because they are asked to play in different positions.
      However this child who recently left the club I work at and many in my experience was just happy to play wherever they were asked to. It was the father who thought he should play in the one position so I presume he could understand my comments but didn’t accept them.
      I don’t have your experience but I have only come across one young player who simply didn’t want to play in any other position other than right wing and I have always thought the majority of the issues stemmed from outside influences as his parents were going through a messy divorce and he had recently moved both house and school so was very unsettled.
      Do you agree that children if possible should be rotated between positions.

      Like

  2. Hi Sean,

    I can definitely relate. We have been coaching and playing Horst Wein 3V3 matches for the U8 for some time now and the children have been enjoying it until lately parents have complained that their children don’t learn “strict positional duties”. Our whole point was to set up a system where all kids learn all positions etc.. we haven’t decided yet what to do, lose kids but maintain a solid all rounded development program or please the noisy parents who are thinking of leaving anyway.

    Like

    • Often trying to please other people ends up pleasing no one as I am sure you are aware.
      The club I am at currently has put it on the registration form stating that all players will be rotated through positions. We shall see how effective it is over the long term.
      Thanks for getting in touch.

      Like

  3. I let all youth teams play the same way, like the first team. I always put the emphasis on learning. Sometimes I had the suspicion the youth coaches were more concerned with winning. They cared about their own reputation. I cared only about the interest of the club. When a player with talent couln’t defend, I put him in defense so he could learn, but that could cost a point. But I didnt care, I was busy developing the player.

    JOHAN CRUYFF:

    Like

    • The more I work with clubs the more I think this comment has relevance ‘They care about their own reputation’. The coaches are more concerned about how they look and then hide behind the comment that the players want to win so feel they can do whatever it takes to win games.
      I think Coaches need to be chosen as carefully as players and not based purely on coaching ability but also by character.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s